mature masturbate solo

    31506 Videos
    Popular
    Latest
    All
    Long
    Stassi Rossi: The Tighter, The Better
    42 sec.
    Stassi Rossi: The Tighter, The Better
    Stassi Rossi solo ass show
    8 months ago
    Abxxx
    EuropeMaturE Busty Lady Lulu Solo Masturbation
    8:09
    EuropeMaturE Busty Lady Lulu Solo Masturbation
    solo mature boobs hot cougar
    3 years ago
    Porncake
    Blessed Palace - Asian PLUS-SIZE Housewife Kyoko Ikenaga Faps
    17:20
    Blessed Palace - Asian PLUS-SIZE Housewife Kyoko Ikenaga Faps
    amateur bbw mature amateur bbw solo
    4 years ago
    PornDR
    Aletta Ocean hot MILF solo masturbation
    15:20
    Aletta Ocean hot MILF solo masturbation
    Aletta Ocean solo masturbation
    3 years ago
    Analdin
    Curvy step-sister and stunning sister-in-law explore their primal lust for the first time
    8:14
    Curvy step-sister and stunning sister-in-law explore their primal lust for the first time
    british first time desi step
    2 months ago
    Videosection
    Mature in Stockings Solo - Mature BBW toys her wet pussy with her favorite dildo
    31:03
    Mature in Stockings Solo - Mature BBW toys her wet pussy with her favorite dildo
    amateur mature plump big dildo solo
    12 months ago
    Xhand
    INTRODUCING BRENDA DOUGLAS, OUR NEW 60PLUS MILF - Brenda douglas
    15:59
    INTRODUCING BRENDA DOUGLAS, OUR NEW 60PLUS MILF - Brenda douglas
    anal big milf natural big tits anal
    3 years ago
    Xtits
    Granny solo - horny ass-fuck
    9:14
    Granny solo - horny ass-fuck
    anal please stop not in my ass
    3 years ago
    HogTV
    Sexual Excitement In The Restroom Scene 3
    11:10
    Sexual Excitement In The Restroom Scene 3
    asian mature asian piss solo
    5 years ago
    Txxx
    A pregnant Valentine masturbates to orgasm
    6:14
    A pregnant Valentine masturbates to orgasm
    big milfs solo first hairy
    3 months ago
    Hotmovs
    alicexsquirt camel toe
    10:47
    alicexsquirt camel toe
    what is the name of girl boobs
    2 years ago
    Uiporn
    Watch this curvy amateur babe toy her phat pussy with a massive dildo in this solo female orgasm video
    19:31
    Watch this curvy amateur babe toy her phat pussy with a massive dildo in this solo female orgasm video
    amateur milf solo dildo toys girl
    4 months ago
    Sexu
    Milf solo masturbation, milf solo, solo milf hd
    12:52
    Milf solo masturbation, milf solo, solo milf hd
    amateur milf masturbation
    4 years ago
    Hdsex
    Reagan Foxx - Slutty Step Mother Masturbating With Son
    14:51
    Reagan Foxx - Slutty Step Mother Masturbating With Son
    Reagan Foxx big heels mom solo
    2 years ago
    Hdzog
    Deja Vu
    21:19
    Deja Vu
    amateur ebony bbw ebony amateur
    3 years ago
    Hclips
    Aunt Judys In Spying On Auntie Star Bedroom Masturbation
    20:35
    Aunt Judys In Spying On Auntie Star Bedroom Masturbation
    Aunt Judys milf aunty big tits
    2 years ago
    Upornia
    Masturbating And Self-fucking Ft. Nicolove Sex Doll 26 Min
    8:00
    Masturbating And Self-fucking Ft. Nicolove Sex Doll 26 Min
    Lina Paige uncensored big tits
    9 months ago
    Porntop
    Dildo races the lonely nympho down the flood of lust and passion
    8:00
    Dildo races the lonely nympho down the flood of lust and passion
    Jessica Starling amateur big dildo
    3 years ago
    Sexvid
    Irresistible Carol Brown's curvy smut
    10:31
    Irresistible Carol Brown's curvy smut
    Carol Brown british short hair
    7 months ago
    Pornhat
    Busty Babe Dildo Fucks Her Wet Pussy and Squirts
    10:36
    Busty Babe Dildo Fucks Her Wet Pussy and Squirts
    babes pussy back of pussy solo
    1 month ago
    PornGem
    Bedroom Pussy Fingering - Kristina Grace Mature Pleasure - Masturbation
    15:15
    Bedroom Pussy Fingering - Kristina Grace Mature Pleasure - Masturbation
    female masturbation pussy fingering
    3 months ago
    Xhand
    Hot And Naughty Mom Masturbating On The Couch - MatureNL
    2:30
    Hot And Naughty Mom Masturbating On The Couch - MatureNL
    female masturbation milf lingerie
    2 years ago
    Hotmovs
    A Quiet Squirter 2. A Busty Pinup
    12:37
    A Quiet Squirter 2. A Busty Pinup
    Macey Jade busty solo dildo
    2 years ago
    Beeg
    Ciel's solo play turns into steamy masturbation with her favorite toys
    8:59
    Ciel's solo play turns into steamy masturbation with her favorite toys
    blonde female masturbation milf
    2 months ago
    HogTV
    Glamour Leggy Milf Solo Masturbation
    8:00
    Glamour Leggy Milf Solo Masturbation
    blonde milf solo solo female
    1 year ago
    Manysex
    Japanese Pornstar Wakaba Onoue's Solo Finger Fucking Play - Must Watch!
    5:08
    Japanese Pornstar Wakaba Onoue's Solo Finger Fucking Play - Must Watch!
    Wakaba Onoue japanese big milf
    3 months ago
    JapanWhores
    Mature older women, mature cougar milf, mature solo
    11:45
    Mature older women, mature cougar milf, mature solo
    british milf solo cougar masturbate
    5 days ago
    Hdsex
    Hot mature women, cougar solo
    11:45
    Hot mature women, cougar solo
    Danielle Tee Louise Pearce Bethany Sweet
    4 days ago
    Videosection
    Cute dusky mom Nila Mason making guy happy by giving an amazing handjob
    7:59
    Cute dusky mom Nila Mason making guy happy by giving an amazing handjob
    Nila Mason back ass shy milf
    3 years ago
    Pornpapa
    Lovely Japanese lady in a sexy solo session
    5:01
    Lovely Japanese lady in a sexy solo session
    asian masturbation solo asian toy
    3 years ago
    Sexy9
    PORNSTARPLATINUM Busty MILF Diamond Foxxx Masturbates Solo
    10:00
    PORNSTARPLATINUM Busty MILF Diamond Foxxx Masturbates Solo
    Diamond Foxxx Diamond Foxx
    3 years ago
    Txxx
    Juicy Yumi Maeda is fingering her twat
    11:36
    Juicy Yumi Maeda is fingering her twat
    Yumi Maeda fingered uncensored
    4 years ago
    Xxxfiles
    Blonde MILF Elara Elis masturbates in the kitchen with a 4K UltraHD view
    7:52
    Blonde MILF Elara Elis masturbates in the kitchen with a 4K UltraHD view
    blonde kitchen milf solo mature
    2 months ago
    Sexu
    asian solo - Mature
    50:33
    asian solo - Mature
    perfect tits asian girl ass solo
    3 years ago
    Analdin
    Mature Milf Charlee Chase Finger Fucks Her Pussy Smoking Cig
    4:52
    Mature Milf Charlee Chase Finger Fucks Her Pussy Smoking Cig
    Charlee Chase blonde solo ts
    3 years ago
    Bigwank
    Flirtatious Fernanda Jones - high heels xxx - Mature NL Solo
    10:27
    Flirtatious Fernanda Jones - high heels xxx - Mature NL Solo
    high heels big ass busty may solo
    3 weeks ago
    Pornhat
    English cougar Belle fondles her own booty
    12:39
    English cougar Belle fondles her own booty
    british milf british mature mom
    1 week ago
    Matureclub
    Hot Asian Girl Masturbates and Orgasms in Public
    5:15
    Hot Asian Girl Masturbates and Orgasms in Public
    what is the name of girl
    2 years ago
    Fapguru
    EuropeMaturE Horny Mature Candy Solo Masturbation
    8:16
    EuropeMaturE Horny Mature Candy Solo Masturbation
    big tits mature masturbation
    3 years ago
    Titshub
    Hot brunette Roxy Mendez in lingerie diligently fucks her cunt
    5:48
    Hot brunette Roxy Mendez in lingerie diligently fucks her cunt
    Roxy Mendez big tits solo mature
    1 year ago
    Megatube
    Solo Japanese MILF is filming herself masturbating
    7:45
    Solo Japanese MILF is filming herself masturbating
    amateur japanese solo masturbation
    4 years ago
    Pornid
    Instead of cooking breakfast MILF masturbates on the table
    8:00
    Instead of cooking breakfast MILF masturbates on the table
    Cherie Deville cooking anal
    3 years ago
    HdTube
    Japanese Porn Star Neiro Suzuka's Busty Dildo Play
    5:10
    Japanese Porn Star Neiro Suzuka's Busty Dildo Play
    Neiro Suzuka japanese big tits
    3 months ago
    JapanWhores
    Masturbating And Self-fucking Ft 26 Min With Lina Paige And Nico Love
    25:58
    Masturbating And Self-fucking Ft 26 Min With Lina Paige And Nico Love
    Lina Paige asian big tits outside
    9 months ago
    Vjav
    Redhead horny lady with big natural tits masturbating solo
    9:46
    Redhead horny lady with big natural tits masturbating solo
    amateur milf busty milf solo
    4 years ago
    Pornoxo
    Tiffany Makes A Slow Start - Anal toys solo masturbation
    17:08
    Tiffany Makes A Slow Start - Anal toys solo masturbation
    big ass mature gets big women solo
    11 months ago
    Xtits
    Hot Summer
    13:03
    Hot Summer
    Caroline Ardolino girls in said
    4 years ago
    Porntry
    Naughty babe is doing solo masturbation show for the webcam
    8:00
    Naughty babe is doing solo masturbation show for the webcam
    Alexis Fawx Alexa Cruz babe toy
    4 years ago
    Pornid
    Gorgeous brunette MILF in stocking adores solo masturbation
    7:54
    Gorgeous brunette MILF in stocking adores solo masturbation
    Jelena Jensen busty stockings solo
    4 years ago
    Sexvid
    Juicy buxomy Airu Oshima
    14:06
    Juicy buxomy Airu Oshima
    Airu Oshima asian big solo
    4 years ago
    Veryfreeporn
    Inked MILF with big tits masturbates in front of web camera
    6:15
    Inked MILF with big tits masturbates in front of web camera
    big tits lingerie brunette lingerie
    3 years ago
    RatXXX
    mature #10
    14:37
    mature #10
    less mature milf masturbation
    4 years ago
    Porntry
    Super Hairy Bitch Housewife - housewife
    22:03
    Super Hairy Bitch Housewife - housewife
    mature fetish granny outdoor solo
    5 years ago
    Xozilla
    Naughty MILF playing by the fire place
    10:10
    Naughty MILF playing by the fire place
    less mature masturbation toys
    4 years ago
    Xxxfiles
    British milf Cassie strips off and dildos her fanny
    12:18
    British milf Cassie strips off and dildos her fanny
    Cassie Clarke british pussy mom
    1 year ago
    Bigwank
    Ukrainian mom Sasha Zima masturbates her cock hungry bare twat
    7:31
    Ukrainian mom Sasha Zima masturbates her cock hungry bare twat
    Sasha Zima anal boobs anal
    4 years ago
    Megatube
    Latina brunette with monster jugs toy fucks herself on cam
    7:54
    Latina brunette with monster jugs toy fucks herself on cam
    Sofia Rose busty solo dildo
    1 month ago
    Letsporn
    MILF enjoyed deep solo pussy fucking before she gave a perfect blowjob
    6:00
    MILF enjoyed deep solo pussy fucking before she gave a perfect blowjob
    natural big tits tit wank
    1 year ago
    ItsPorn
    Victoria Vale: The Enormous Size of Victoria's Busty Bosoms! INCREDIBLE!
    7:34
    Victoria Vale: The Enormous Size of Victoria's Busty Bosoms! INCREDIBLE!
    tit wank busty blond solo milf
    7 months ago
    Matureclub
    Blonde Big Tits MILF hottie Katlynn fingers her pussy in lingerie and fucks herself with toys
    6:54
    Blonde Big Tits MILF hottie Katlynn fingers her pussy in lingerie and fucks herself with toys
    busty lingerie solo blonde milf ass
    2 years ago
    Fapguru
    Hot Milf Solo
    12:18
    Hot Milf Solo
    mature amateur masturbation head
    5 years ago
    Hclips
    slutty horny hongkong camgirl milf
    10:16
    slutty horny hongkong camgirl milf
    world's big boobs milf squirt
    2 weeks ago
    Abxxx
    Shiho Terashima - masturbating in the bathroom
    9:21
    Shiho Terashima - masturbating in the bathroom
    asian big tits asian milf solo
    2 months ago
    Abjav
    Box Of Porn - boxofporn porn
    15:51
    Box Of Porn - boxofporn porn
    Kate Faucett redhead orgasm talk
    11 months ago
    OkXXX
    Pawg Mom Virgo Peridot Porn Video
    37:18
    Pawg Mom Virgo Peridot Porn Video
    Virgo Peridot big ass maid facial
    4 years ago
    Analdin
    Aunt Judy's Big Tit MILFs - Busty Mature MILF Mrs. Molly - Outdoor Office Meeting
    19:59
    Aunt Judy's Big Tit MILFs - Busty Mature MILF Mrs. Molly - Outdoor Office Meeting
    Aunt Judys blonde tits mature
    5 months ago
    Pornhub
    Beautiful Ebony Model Candace West Solo Strip Down And Pussy Masturbation
    7:59
    Beautiful Ebony Model Candace West Solo Strip Down And Pussy Masturbation
    Candace West amateur w big tits
    1 year ago
    Blackporn
    Jos phine de l' le Maurice : Mature, poilue, elle s'exhibe et se branle
    8:39
    Jos phine de l' le Maurice : Mature, poilue, elle s'exhibe et se branle
    amateur glasses euro mature
    4 years ago
    HogTV
    An older woman means fun part 442
    18:35
    An older woman means fun part 442
    masturbation tits solo milf tits
    3 years ago
    Upornia
    Scorching cougar Danielle lets her pearl get bigger and glow with a hookup fucktoy
    12:25
    Scorching cougar Danielle lets her pearl get bigger and glow with a hookup fucktoy
    Devon Breeze solo big butt amateur
    3 years ago
    Uiporn
    Chubby Aunt Montse
    9:24
    Chubby Aunt Montse
    chubby brazilian chubby mature solo
    4 years ago
    HogTV
    EuropeMature Collecting Solo Toys Masturbation
    8:31
    EuropeMature Collecting Solo Toys Masturbation
    mature compilation milf mature
    4 years ago
    Hdzog
    Older woman in fishnets masturbates on camera
    7:44
    Older woman in fishnets masturbates on camera
    big ass solo milf mature fingering
    1 year ago
    Xozilla
    Incredible Japanese slut in Best Mature, Solo Female JAV scene
    6:56
    Incredible Japanese slut in Best Mature, Solo Female JAV scene
    fetish female masturbation milf
    5 years ago
    Abxxx
    Indian big bootie MILF solo masturbation
    11:52
    Indian big bootie MILF solo masturbation
    amateur milf big tits fuck
    2 years ago
    HomemadeXXX
    Nasty mature Kelly Madison masturbates on the floor
    7:49
    Nasty mature Kelly Madison masturbates on the floor
    Kelly Madison busty milf boobs
    2 years ago
    Milffox
    Crystal Swift in Huge Naturals - Anilos
    7:59
    Crystal Swift in Huge Naturals - Anilos
    Crystal Swift anilos blonde
    5 years ago
    Txxx
    Blonde milf Ashleigh from the UK finger fucks her hot cunt
    12:24
    Blonde milf Ashleigh from the UK finger fucks her hot cunt
    blonde milf mother solo english
    2 years ago
    Porncake
    Latex Lady With Pink Pussy - Rubber Girl Solo Masturbation Juicy Vagina (arya Grander) Blonde Milf
    7:13
    Latex Lady With Pink Pussy - Rubber Girl Solo Masturbation Juicy Vagina (arya Grander) Blonde Milf
    Arya Grander big pussy masturbation
    10 months ago
    Bdsmx
    Luscious Blond Aletta Ocean Masturbation Clip
    15:28
    Luscious Blond Aletta Ocean Masturbation Clip
    Aletta Ocean aletta ocean
    3 years ago
    Analdin
    MILF in body stocking Masturbates
    8:05
    MILF in body stocking Masturbates
    Emylia Argan big tits lingerie
    1 year ago
    Beeg
    bottomless solo masturbation
    3:25
    bottomless solo masturbation
    amateur foot fetish milf voyeur
    3 years ago
    Voyeurhit
    Maki Hojo in Maki solo session - MilfsInJapan
    6:00
    Maki Hojo in Maki solo session - MilfsInJapan
    Maki Hojo asian solo masturbation
    7 years ago
    Hotmovs
    Hairy MILF stepmom masturbates solo for nympho stepson
    9:10
    Hairy MILF stepmom masturbates solo for nympho stepson
    finger up ass masturbation
    1 year ago
    Abxxx
    Hot basketball match and sloppy blowjob
    6:00
    Hot basketball match and sloppy blowjob
    hot babe solo babe hard big cock
    1 year ago
    PornGem
    Nikita masturbates with her purple ball toys
    6:15
    Nikita masturbates with her purple ball toys
    mature ass solo big women solo
    7 months ago
    Abxxx
    Naughty MILF playing by the fire place
    10:01
    Naughty MILF playing by the fire place
    fire place milf masturbation
    4 years ago
    Veryfreeporn
    Super sexy milf makes herself cum
    9:19
    Super sexy milf makes herself cum
    amateur amateur lingerie
    5 months ago
    RockPorn
    Helena caught HCM alone
    10:02
    Helena caught HCM alone
    amateur milf orgasm milf ass solo
    5 months ago
    Txxx
    Brie Daniels, the divorced MILF, gets naughty with herself in 4K Ultra HD
    10:04
    Brie Daniels, the divorced MILF, gets naughty with herself in 4K Ultra HD
    daddy solo father y mother
    5 months ago
    Senioras
    Busty Sexy Milf Solo Masturbation
    8:00
    Busty Sexy Milf Solo Masturbation
    amateur brunette amateur women
    1 year ago
    Xmilf
    Sexual Excitement In The Restroom - Scene 1
    11:06
    Sexual Excitement In The Restroom - Scene 1
    asian female masturbation
    5 years ago
    Txxx
    Hot redhead MILF Dani Jensen masturbates on the table
    5:29
    Hot redhead MILF Dani Jensen masturbates on the table
    Dani Jensen big tits fuck
    2 years ago
    Definebabe
    An Yabuki Milf Asian Amateur Masturbates In Stockings
    11:54
    An Yabuki Milf Asian Amateur Masturbates In Stockings
    asian amateur asian hairy solo
    4 years ago
    Vjav
    Cheating Slut Wife Masturbate With Big Dildos And Real Cum In Her Pussy! She Will Get Pregnant From This For Sure - Cum Play Compilation - Milky Mari 13 Min
    13:14
    Cheating Slut Wife Masturbate With Big Dildos And Real Cum In Her Pussy! She Will Get Pregnant From This For Sure - Cum Play Compilation - Milky Mari 13 Min
    amateur penis hairy pussy ass
    9 months ago
    Hdzog
    Amateur Blonde MOM with Glasses Solo Masturbation
    5:52
    Amateur Blonde MOM with Glasses Solo Masturbation
    german amateur dutch solo next
    4 years ago
    PornDR
    Beautiful Milf Masturbating On Bed - Lydia V
    8:00
    Beautiful Milf Masturbating On Bed - Lydia V
    curvy solo brunette solo
    3 years ago
    Porntop
    Mega-Star Stormy Daniels Performs an Exclusive Webcam Show on Flirt4Free
    11:56
    Mega-Star Stormy Daniels Performs an Exclusive Webcam Show on Flirt4Free
    Stormy Daniels amateur tattoo
    5 years ago
    Hclips
    Heavenly brunette MILF Tori Black having a wonderful time by Masturbating
    9:59
    Heavenly brunette MILF Tori Black having a wonderful time by Masturbating
    Tori Black black ass kitchen time
    3 years ago
    Pornpapa
    Lady Gendolina - Horny Neighbour; Huge Tits Blonde Mature Milf Solo
    2:00
    Lady Gendolina - Horny Neighbour; Huge Tits Blonde Mature Milf Solo
    big blonde solo huge natural tits
    2 years ago
    Vxxx
    Macy-Nihongo - 4some Deluxe With A Ladyboy
    30 sec.
    Macy-Nihongo - 4some Deluxe With A Ladyboy
    asian big tits asian big tits solo
    2 years ago
    Txxx
    Amazing Japanese whore in Exotic MILF, Masturbation JAV scene
    13:09
    Amazing Japanese whore in Exotic MILF, Masturbation JAV scene
    perfect tits milf exotic solo
    12 months ago
    Xjav
    MatureNL 5
    14:37
    MatureNL 5
    less mature masturbation toys
    4 years ago
    Porngo
    Amateur Milf Double Penetration Masturbation Until Orgasm
    10:13
    Amateur Milf Double Penetration Masturbation Until Orgasm
    amateur milf hairy solo milf anal
    2 months ago
    Videosection
    Juicy Pussy Fuck And Anal Plug Solo Masturbation Phone Video Homemade By Arya Grander - Compilation
    8:00
    Juicy Pussy Fuck And Anal Plug Solo Masturbation Phone Video Homemade By Arya Grander - Compilation
    Arya Grander pussy anal ts pussy
    1 year ago
    Inporn
    Classy buxomy Japanese MILF Yuuko Shiraki Featuring Masturbation porn video outside
    7:49
    Classy buxomy Japanese MILF Yuuko Shiraki Featuring Masturbation porn video outside
    Yuuko Shiraki asian big solo
    3 years ago
    Videojav
    Milf solo
    11:55
    Milf solo
    big milf solo busty milf solo
    5 years ago
    Txxx
    Posh MILF In Lingerie
    10:52
    Posh MILF In Lingerie
    blonde masturbation mature solo
    6 years ago
    Analdin
    Mature solo, recent, mom solo hot
    18:40
    Mature solo, recent, mom solo hot
    mom come home mature masturbation
    3 years ago
    Hdsex
    Supersized SBBW redhead MILF Tiffany Star dicked and loves it
    32:24
    Supersized SBBW redhead MILF Tiffany Star dicked and loves it
    Tiffany Star solo ass masturbation
    5 years ago
    Analdin
    Incredible Japanese slut in Best Mature, Solo Female JAV scene
    6:56
    Incredible Japanese slut in Best Mature, Solo Female JAV scene
    female masturbation milf solo
    5 years ago
    Txxx
    Webcam Milf With Breast Milk Live Hardcore Masturbate
    11:06
    Webcam Milf With Breast Milk Live Hardcore Masturbate
    pregnant milf brunette solo fetish
    2 years ago
    Hclips
    Japanese stepmom kinky and alone
    9:06
    Japanese stepmom kinky and alone
    asian milf ass japanese stepmom
    3 years ago
    HogTV
    Ryan Conner super elastic ass gets probed
    9:22
    Ryan Conner super elastic ass gets probed
    Ryan Conner busty interracial
    3 years ago
    HogTV
    My wife shaves her armpits
    12:02
    My wife shaves her armpits
    hairy solo mom come home
    5 years ago
    Analdin
    Nikki and Harley's hardcore sex
    6:29
    Nikki and Harley's hardcore sex
    Nikki Silver Harley Hex Simone Delilah
    5 months ago
    Pornhat
    Big natural tits solo, big tit milf, mature solo
    5:10
    Big natural tits solo, big tit milf, mature solo
    amateur mature tits milf
    5 years ago
    Hdsex
    Mother Of My Best Friend Caught Masturbating When Im Around
    5:43
    Mother Of My Best Friend Caught Masturbating When Im Around
    amateur women amateur solo mom
    1 year ago
    Hclips
    Syrian Girl Masturbates Souzanhalabi
    3:09
    Syrian Girl Masturbates Souzanhalabi
    amateur masturbation amateur webcam
    3 years ago
    Hclips
    Gorgeous blonde BBW plays solo with her favorite brown dildo
    8:00
    Gorgeous blonde BBW plays solo with her favorite brown dildo
    solo blonde big ass hd milf squirt
    3 years ago
    Sexvid

    Popular Searches

    aleah jasmine applejack consolation cum huge wife erotic stripping fuck girlfriend and her mom granny flowers julia ann lesbians hot orgasm eating julie skyhugh mary jean and chris strokes milky tits and squirting mistress dominates norway opa german sensual jane stockings two cute boys yago nervous teenager jessica malone pissing virtual sex cousin asean vs black